Evidence

How we grade

Three letters, applied without flattery. A grade states how far the evidence reaches, never how much we like the plant.

A
Multiple randomised trials or a meta-analysis

Independent replication with consistent direction of effect.

B
Limited clinical evidence

Human trials exist but are few, small, or not yet replicated.

C
Pre-clinical work or documented traditional use only

The honest starting point of most botanical literature, and of most of our library.

The seven rungs

Beneath every grade sits a ladder showing where the evidence stands. A low rung is candour, not failure. We do not use softer words in place of the letters: they are less falsifiable, and this library exists to be checked.

The grades beside each rung are indicative, not automatic. A rung records that evidence of that kind exists; the grade records what it actually showed, and for which use. A botanical can reach the systematic-review rung and still hold a C, because the review found little, or because it examined a different preparation or a different complaint than the one the entry concerns. Where those diverge, the entry says so.

  1. VIISystematic reviewGrade A
  2. VIClinical studiesGrade A–B
  3. VHuman observationalGrade B–C
  4. IVPreclinicalGrade C
  5. IIILaboratoryGrade C
  6. IIPhytochemicalGrade C
  7. ITraditional useGrade C

“Traditional use is the beginning of a question, not the end of the answer.”

The Botanika Nusantara standard
Two kinds of page

Not every page in the library carries a grade, and the difference is deliberate.

A dictionary entry documents a plant: its names, where it grows, and what the heritage, culinary, ritual and trade records say about it, with every statement cited. It makes no assessment of what the plant does to the body, so it carries no grade.

A Health monograph is the assessment: the evidence weighed and graded A, B or C, the ladder position, the phytochemistry, and the safety and interactions section. Only entries in the Health category carry one.

The tradition is recorded as soon as it is sourced, and the evidence is graded only in a Health monograph.

How a monograph is made
1Drafted from primary sources
2Every reference checked to exist before it is entered
3Graded against this standard; safety section mandatory
4Updated when new evidence appears